NFL Focus Groups - Doritos Crash the Super Bowl 2025 - Ad Analysis
AI Editor notes
Straight from the gut!!
“It's a smart, safe teaser. Using the Chiefs is timely and the humor is gentle—playing on the trope of jocks being bad at 'artsy' stuff like ad analysis. But does it have teeth? It feels more like a required piece of communication to announce the contest than a truly hilarious, standalone ad. Its success hinges entirely on the audience already knowing and caring about the 'Crash the Super Bowl' platform.”
Quick Summary
This ad cleverly uses meta-humor by casting highly famous NFL players as clueless 'expert' ad critics to promote the return of Doritos' signature 'Crash the Super Bowl' fan-made ad contest. The goal isn't to sell chips directly, but to use the players' celebrity to drive engagement for the contest itself, reinforcing Doritos' brand personality as fun, self-aware, and connected to the Super Bowl spectacle.
Executive Summary
Doritos revives its classic 'Crash the Super Bowl' playbook with a meta-comedic spot that understands its place in the Super Bowl ecosystem. The ad, titled 'NFL Focus Group,' isn't trying to be the main event; it's the usher guiding you to the real show. By positioning Kansas City Chiefs players as a panel of comically inept 'Super Bowl experts,' the brand cleverly subverts the very idea of celebrity endorsement.
The Core Insight here is twofold: first, that in the age of social media, every viewer is an ad critic, and second, that there's inherent humor in seeing people who are masters of one domain (pro football) be complete novices in another (creative evaluation). Doritos leverages this by making the audience the real expert, empowering them to judge the fan-made ads that the pros are unqualified to assess.
The execution follows a simple Setup-Turn-Payoff structure. The Setup (0:00-0:09) establishes a familiar, sterile focus group environment where a moderator explains the task: review fan-made Super Bowl commercials. The Turn (0:09-0:45) is the reveal that the focus group consists of Patrick Mahomes, Chris Jones, Creed Humphrey, and Xavier Worthy. The humor isn't from slapstick but from their deadpan, literal-minded feedback. Creed Humphrey liking 'the one with the chip' and the collective agreement that the ads are 'very cheesy' are lines that work precisely because they are so unhelpful. The comedic peak is the meta-joke where Chris Jones and Patrick Mahomes agree it's 'weird to see a commercial without Patrick in it,' a nod to Mahomes' ubiquitous presence in advertising. The Payoff (0:55-1:01) is the direct call-to-action, making the entire preceding sketch a humorous preamble to the real message: 'Vote for the Doritos Super Bowl Ad.'
The Debrief for the team is that celebrity can be used for more than just a famous face; it can be a tool for self-parody that reinforces brand personality. This ad doesn't ask you to buy Doritos because Patrick Mahomes eats them. It invites you into the brand's world—a world that is fun, doesn't take itself too seriously, and values its fans' opinions over even a Super Bowl champion's. It's a smart, efficient piece of communication that activates a larger, fan-centric campaign.
Theme Keywords
Brand Position
The bold, fun snack that invites everyone to the party.
Brand Archetype
Jester
Creative Game Plan
Use famous NFL players' comedic lack of advertising expertise to humorously set up the real proposition: empowering fans to be the true judges of our Super Bowl commercial.
Diagnosis: Issues & Solutions
Primary Issue: Emotional Connection
The Problem:
The humor is consistently light and amusing but never escalates to a truly memorable, laugh-out-loud moment. It generates smiles but lacks the comedic punch to become highly shareable on its own merits.
The Solution:
Sharpen the script with a more unexpected or absurd comedic turn. For example, have one of the players offer an incredibly overwrought, jargon-filled critique that is hilariously wrong, creating a stronger comedic contrast.
Secondary Issue: Clarity of "What's Next?"
The Problem:
The ad clearly directs people to vote but fails to communicate the stakes of the contest. Viewers are unaware that the winning filmmaker receives $1 million and a life-changing career opportunity, which is a compelling human-interest angle. [1, 7]
The Solution:
Incorporate a simple text overlay or a closing VO line: 'One fan will win $1 million and a spot in the Super Bowl. You pick the winner.' This immediately adds gravity and a stronger incentive for the audience to participate.
Additional Notes
Related Links
Credits
Share this Analysis
More Doritos ad breakdowns
- Doritos UFODoritos
- SLING BABY | Doritos Commercial | #superbowl #commercialsDoritos
- A Spicy But Not Too Spicy PlumberDoritos
- Day Of The Dead — Doritos [ English subs ] LGBT+ Día de MuertosDoritos
- DORITOS "FINGER CLEANER" - 2014 CRASH THE SUPER BOWL FINALISTDoritos
- The Triangle TheoryDoritos
- Doritos 2016 Super Bowl CommercialDoritos
- Four footballers looking for a bar…but not just any bar 👀#NoWalkersNoGameWalkers