Give Them Tomorrow 2017: Lullacry - Ad Analysis

March of Dimes
Non-profit / Charitable Organization
Social Responsibility
Give Them Tomorrow 2017: Lullacry
Experimental
8/10
Powerhouse
The ad's primary objective is to build the brand by creating a deep emotional connection to its mission. It succeeds exceptionally well by sacrificing initial comfort for a powerful, memorable message that is perfectly on-brand. The trade-off is effective and justifies the high score.
Clarity Of Message
The ad's core message—that a cry is a precious sign of life—is delivered with exceptional power and clarity after the initial setup. The turn from noise to 'music' makes the point unforgettable.
Brand Distinctiveness
This concept is highly ownable for March of Dimes. No other type of organization could make this specific claim with such credibility. It perfectly aligns with their focus on maternal and infant health.
Memorability And Hook
The hook is the abrasive sound of crying itself. It's intentionally jarring and impossible to ignore, making the ad and its subsequent emotional resolution highly memorable.
Emotional Resonance
The ad masterfully creates a journey from anxiety and discomfort to relief and hope. This emotional whiplash is powerful and directly relevant to the fears and joys of childbirth.
Business Objective Fit
As a brand-building and awareness campaign, the ad is exceptionally fit for purpose. It's designed to build emotional equity and reinforce the value of the organization's mission.
Call To Action
The ad provides a clear URL, but the phrase "Get involved" is somewhat generic. A more specific or tangible call to action could have provided a stronger final push.
AI Expert Avatar

AI Editor notes

Straight from the gut!!

It's a gutsy move. Starting an ad with 15 straight seconds of crying babies is a huge gamble designed to make you uncomfortable. But the pivot to "Every cry is music to our ears" is what makes it work. It's smart, jarring, emotional judo. You're forced to appreciate a sound you'd normally tune out, which is exactly the point. A very solid piece of creative.

Quick Summary

This ad brilliantly re-frames a universally grating sound—a baby's cry—as a beautiful symbol of life. By turning discomfort into hope, it makes the March of Dimes' mission to ensure healthy births feel immediate, visceral, and profoundly important.

Executive Summary

The core insight driving this March of Dimes spot is a powerful truth known to anyone who has worried about the health of a newborn: the sound that most people find irritating—a baby's cry—is, for a parent who has faced uncertainty, the most beautiful sound in the world. It is the sound of life, of breath, and of a future. This ad's success lies in its ability to transfer that profound parental perspective to a general audience in just 30 seconds.

The execution follows a classic Setup-Turn-Payoff structure, built entirely around sound design. The Setup is deliberately abrasive. For the first 15 seconds, the viewer is subjected to a raw, unfiltered montage of babies crying, amplified and layered to create an uncomfortable wall of sound. The quick cuts between infants in distress, some in clinical incubators, build a palpable sense of anxiety. This is a bold choice that risks viewer tune-out, but it's essential for the emotional payoff. The Turn occurs precisely at the halfway mark. A simple, hopeful piano melody emerges, and the on-screen text appears: 'Every cry...' This is the pivot point where the ad begins to resolve the tension it has created. The Payoff immediately follows as the sentence completes: '...is music to our ears.' Suddenly, the crying is no longer noise; it's re-contextualized as a series of notes in a lullaby of life. The visuals soften to show babies being comforted and loved. The final super, 'Help give every mom and baby a brighter, healthier tomorrow,' connects this emotional release directly to the organization's purpose and call to action.

The debrief for the creative team would center on the effectiveness of re-framing. The campaign, which was part of a larger 'Give Them Tomorrow' initiative, demonstrates that taking a negative or uncomfortable stimulus and revealing its hidden positive meaning can create a potent and memorable message. [1] It’s a masterclass in emotional storytelling that proves a strong, simple insight can be more powerful than a massive production budget. The ad's bravery in using an irritating sound as its primary tool is what makes it not just good, but noteworthy.

Theme Keywords

Non-profit
Social Responsibility
Emotional Appeal
Healthcare
Infant Health

Brand Position

The essential champion for the health of every mother and baby, providing a fighting chance from the very first breath.

Brand Archetype

The Caregiver

Creative Game Plan

Re-frame the universally recognized sound of a baby's cry from an annoyance into a beautiful and precious symbol of life that is worth protecting.

Diagnosis: Issues & Solutions

Primary Issue: Clarity of "What's Next?"

The Problem:

The call-to-action 'Get involved' is generic. After creating such a powerful emotional moment, it gives the viewer a vague next step, which can lead to inaction and a lower conversion from awareness to support.

The Solution:

Make the CTA more tangible and link it directly to the creative concept. For example: 'Help us hear another cry. Donate today.' or 'Share this lullaby to give every baby a voice.' This provides a clear, compelling action that feels like a direct extension of the ad's story.

Secondary Issue: Strategic Sense

The Problem:

The ad excels at high-level emotional branding but doesn't connect the feeling to the specific, tangible work that March of Dimes does (e.g., funding research, providing NICU support, advocacy). Viewers feel the 'why' but not the 'how'.

The Solution:

Complement this 'air war' spot with a 'ground war' of targeted content. Create short-form videos or social posts that show exactly how a donation leads to 'more music'—funding a specific research project, supporting a family through the NICU, or enabling a legislative win.

Additional Notes

Credits

Title:Give Them Tomorrow 2017: Lullacry
Brand:March of Dimes
Product Category:Non-profit / Charitable Organization
Campaign Category:Social Responsibility,Brand Building
Campaign Objective:Social Responsibility
Creative Format:Lifestyle/Aspirational
Visual Style:Live Action
Target Audience Primary:Multi-generational
Geographic Scope:National
Platform Focus:Connected TV/OTT
Cultural Context:Year-round/Evergreen
Market Position:Market Leader
Runtime:0:30
Geography:United States
Agency:Barkley
Creative Team:Katy Hornaday (EVP, Executive Creative Director),Berk Wasserman (VP, Group Creative Director),Matt Pruett (Creative Director),Kyle Anthony (Associate Creative Director),Joe DeSalvo (Associate Creative Director)
Production Company:Barkley Films
Campaign Launch Date:2017-09

Share this Analysis