FRONTIER ANIMAL AUDITIONS: PART 2 - Ad Analysis

Frontier Airlines
Airline
Brand Building
FRONTIER ANIMAL AUDITIONS: PART 2
Experimental
8/10
Powerhouse
This campaign is an exceptional piece of brand building. It sacrifices a hard-sell message for entertainment and engagement, a strategic trade-off that pays off by making the brand more beloved and memorable in a commoditized category. It brilliantly activates a unique brand asset and turns it into a conversation.
Clarity Of Message
The core message—that Frontier is a fun, unique airline and you can help pick the next animal—is perfectly clear. The audition framework makes the concept instantly understandable.
Brand Distinctiveness
This ad is impossible for any other airline to run. It's built entirely around Frontier's most ownable brand asset, making it the definition of distinctive.
Memorability And Hook
The opening hook of a talking cow on a plane tail is strong. The rapid succession of funny, quirky animal characters makes the overall spot memorable and highly shareable for its time.
Emotional Resonance
The ad generates a consistent feeling of lighthearted fun and humor. While not deeply emotional, the charm and wit create a strong positive association with the brand.
Business Objective Fit
As a brand-building and engagement campaign, this is a perfect fit. It's not designed to sell tickets tomorrow, but to build long-term brand affinity, which it does effectively.
Call To Action
The call to 'Help us choose at FrontierAirlines.com' is direct, simple, and integrated into the narrative. It gives the audience a clear, compelling reason to engage further.
AI Expert Avatar

AI Editor notes

Straight from the gut!!

This is a clever, classic brand-building play. It's long for 2025, but for 2012 this was prime YouTube content. The whole 'audition' concept is a perfect vehicle for the brand's humor and gives them an excuse to show off dozens of potential new tail designs. It feels authentic to the brand—a little low-budget, a little goofy, but charming. It's smart because it's not just an ad; it's an event.

Quick Summary

Frontier Airlines turned its most recognizable brand asset—the animals on its plane tails—into an interactive entertainment platform. By personifying them in a humorous, mock-audition format, the campaign reinforces the airline's quirky, 'A Whole Different Animal' positioning and drives direct audience engagement by asking them to vote, creating a sense of shared ownership in the brand.

Executive Summary

The 'Animal Auditions' campaign is a strong example of a brand knowing its greatest asset and building an entire narrative world around it. For Frontier, a low-cost carrier, competing on luxury or service is a losing game. Instead, they compete on personality, and their key differentiator has always been the wildlife photography on their aircraft tails. This campaign, created by Grey Worldwide, doesn't just show the animals; it gives them a voice and a stage.

The Core Insight here is that customers don't just see planes; they see characters. People form attachments to 'their' animal and have favorites. The campaign taps into this latent affection by asking a simple, powerful question: If these animals were real, what would they be like? This insight transforms a static design feature into a dynamic source of entertainment and engagement.

The Execution uses a classic 'mockumentary' or reality TV audition format, which was highly relevant in 2012. It follows a simple but effective structure: Setup-Turn-Payoff, repeated in rapid succession with each new animal. The Setup is the animal's introduction. The Turn is the comedic flaw or quirk in their personality (the cow realizing the seats are leather, the turtle's stage fright). The Payoff is the punchline, often delivered by the established animal characters acting as a peanut gallery. This format is efficient, allowing for a high density of jokes that keep the 3-minute-plus runtime from dragging. The mixed-media visual style—combining real plane footage with animated animal faces—is cost-effective and reinforces the charming, slightly unpolished feel of the brand, making it more approachable than its larger, more corporate competitors.

The Debrief for any brand team watching this is clear: find your most unique asset and activate it. Frontier could have just run ads saying 'We have animals on our planes.' Instead, they built a universe. They created an interactive event that invited the audience in, giving them a reason to visit the website that wasn't just 'book a flight.' It's a masterclass in turning a brand feature into a brand platform, creating content that people choose to watch and share, rather than just an ad they have to sit through.

Theme Keywords

Talking Animals
Humorous
Brand Mascot
Interactive Campaign
Airline Advertising

Brand Position

The fun, quirky, and affordable airline that's a 'whole different animal'.

Brand Archetype

Jester

Creative Game Plan

Bring our most unique brand asset to life by creating a humorous, American Idol-style audition for the next animal to be featured on our planes.

Diagnosis: Issues & Solutions

Primary Issue: Strategic Sense

The Problem:

The ad's 3:15 runtime, while suitable for its 2012 YouTube context, is a significant liability in the modern media environment. An audience's attention span is far shorter now, and a single, long-form video is less effective at reaching viewers across different platforms like TikTok, Instagram Reels, or as a pre-roll ad.

The Solution:

Deconstruct the long-form 'audition reel' into a series of 15-20 second standalone spots. Each short ad could feature a single animal's audition, optimized for vertical video and social sharing. This creates more assets, allows for targeted media buys, and makes the content more digestible for contemporary viewing habits.

Secondary Issue: Clarity of "What's Next?"

The Problem:

The call-to-action to 'vote' is clear, but it lacks a direct incentive for the user. It relies purely on the audience's goodwill and entertainment value to drive traffic. In a more competitive digital space, this may not be enough to maximize participation.

The Solution:

Strengthen the call-to-action by adding a simple value exchange. For instance: 'Vote for the next Frontier Animal and get a 10% discount on your next flight' or 'Vote and be entered to win a trip.' This small incentive can significantly increase conversion rates on the desired action.

Additional Notes

Credits

Title:FRONTIER ANIMAL AUDITIONS: PART 2
Brand:Frontier Airlines
Product Category:Airline
Parent Entity:Frontier Group Holdings, Inc.
Campaign Category:Brand Building,Interactive Campaign
Campaign Objective:Brand Awareness
Creative Format:Humorous
Visual Style:Mixed Media
Target Audience Primary:Multi-generational
Geographic Scope:National
Platform Focus:YouTube Pre-roll
Cultural Context:Year-round/Evergreen
Market Position:Challenger
Runtime:3:15
Geography:United States
Agency:Grey Worldwide
Creative Team:Shawn Couzens,Gary Ennis
Campaign Launch Date:2012-03

Share this Analysis