Change I Princess Cruises Short Film Commercial - Ad Analysis

Princess Cruises
Cruise Line
Brand Building
Change I Princess Cruises Short Film Commercial
Experimental
7/10
Promising
The ad succeeds as a piece of premium brand building. It sacrifices distinctiveness for a universally appealing message of transformation, which is a smart trade-off for its objective of elevating the brand's perception. The execution is solid and emotionally resonant, making it an effective, if not groundbreaking, piece of advertising.
Clarity Of Message
The core message—that travel with Princess changes you—is delivered consistently through the captain's narration and the tagline 'come back new.' It's a single, powerful idea.
Brand Distinctiveness
While beautifully shot, the aspirational travel montage is a category convention. The captain narrator is a good touch, but a competitor could easily replicate this 'transformative journey' feel.
Memorability And Hook
The ad is visually impressive but lacks a truly unique, sticky element. The hook is the cinematic quality itself, which grabs attention but may not hold it against more novel creative.
Emotional Resonance
The ad effectively evokes a sense of awe, wonder, and nostalgia for a more connected way of living. The combination of epic scenery and intimate human moments creates a strong emotional pull.
Business Objective Fit
As a brand-building exercise, this is a perfect fit. It aims to establish an emotional, premium territory for Princess, moving the conversation from price and features to a higher-order benefit. This was created for 'wave season' to drive bookings. [6]
Call To Action
The implicit call to action is to book a transformative journey. The tagline 'come back new' clearly frames the expected outcome, and the YouTube description provides the direct link. It's effective for a brand piece.
AI Expert Avatar

AI Editor notes

Straight from the gut!!

This feels like a play straight from the luxury brand handbook. It’s beautiful, expensive, and a little generic. The 'change' concept is powerful but hard to own. Could a competitor like Holland America or even a resort chain run this? Probably. It's trying so hard to be profound that it almost forgets to be about cruising. I'm left with a feeling, but not a sharp reason to choose Princess over another option.

Quick Summary

This ad positions Princess Cruises not as a vacation, but as a catalyst for personal transformation. By framing the journey through the eyes of a wise captain who has witnessed countless lives changed, the brand elevates itself above competitors' focus on amenities and fun, selling a deeper, more profound benefit: you won't just have a good time, you'll 'come back new.'

Executive Summary

Princess Cruises' 'Change' is a textbook example of a brand moving up the value chain, shifting the conversation from the 'what' (ships, destinations) to the 'why' (personal transformation). It’s a deliberate strategy to carve out a premium, emotionally-driven space in a crowded market that often defaults to promoting features like waterslides and buffets.

The Core Insight: The central idea is that modern travelers, particularly the target audience of 'Meaningful Travelers' identified by the brand's research, crave more than just an escape; they seek experiences that enrich and change them. [1, 2] The ad posits that a cruise is not merely a trip but a journey that facilitates profound connections—with nature, with diverse cultures, and most importantly, with loved ones and oneself. The promise isn't a collection of souvenirs, but a renewed perspective on life.

The Execution: The ad uses a classic Lifestyle/Aspirational narrative, anchored by the 'wise observer' archetype—the ship's captain. This is a smart choice. The captain serves as a credible, third-party witness to the transformations he describes, lending authenticity to the lofty claims. The structure follows a simple but effective arc:

  • Setup: The ad opens with breathtaking, cinematic shots of nature and people in moments of quiet wonder. The captain’s voiceover immediately introduces the theme: 'Change.' This establishes a contemplative, premium tone, far from the high-energy chaos of typical cruise ads.
  • The Turn: The narrative builds by defining what this 'change' looks like. It’s not one big event, but a series of small, powerful moments: watching a glacier calve, feeling the rush of a dogsled, sharing a dance, or connecting with an animal. The montage connects these disparate experiences to the core benefit, showing how the cruise facilitates these moments.
  • The Payoff: The voiceover concludes by framing this change as the ultimate return on investment. The line, 'To see people go out... and come back new,' directly pays off the brand's long-standing tagline. The final shot of the ship at sunset is the category-standard punctuation, but here it feels earned, symbolizing the journey towards that 'new' self.

The Debrief: The team behind this ad understood that to command a premium, you have to sell a premium benefit. They successfully identified a target psychographic ('Meaningful Travelers') and built a narrative that speaks directly to their desires. [2] The choice to use a 90-second 'short film' format for digital and TV was also key, allowing the emotional arc to build without feeling rushed. [3, 6] The lesson here is that when your product category is commoditized, the most powerful differentiator is often an intangible feeling. Princess isn't selling cruises; it's selling the person you'll become after the cruise.

Theme Keywords

Transformative Travel
Emotional Appeal
Nature
Human Connection
Brand Storytelling

Brand Position

The cruise line that provides enriching travel experiences that change you for the better.

Brand Archetype

The Sage/Explorer.

Creative Game Plan

Use a seasoned captain's perspective to frame a cruise as a journey that delivers personal transformation through connection with nature, culture, and people.

Diagnosis: Issues & Solutions

Primary Issue: Brand Distinctiveness

The Problem:

The ad's biggest weakness is its reliance on generic, albeit beautiful, imagery of travel. While emotionally effective, the scenes of glaciers, waterfalls, and cultural dances could belong to any premium travel brand, from a competitor cruise line to an airline or a luxury hotel chain.

The Solution:

Integrate more specific, 'only-on-Princess' moments. Instead of just showing a glacier, briefly feature a unique shore excursion or an onboard naturalist program that makes that moment possible. The captain narrator is a step in this direction; the next step is to connect the transformative moments more explicitly to the unique platform that is a Princess ship.

Secondary Issue: Clarity of 'What's Next?'

The Problem:

For a potential customer who is moved by the ad but new to cruising, the spot doesn't provide a clear entry point. The abstract promise of 'change' is compelling but might leave some viewers wondering, 'Okay, but what does that actually look like for me? Which trip do I take?'

The Solution:

Complement the high-level brand film with targeted digital creative. For example, retarget viewers with shorter, 15-second ads showcasing how specific itineraries (e.g., 'The Alaskan Change,' 'The Mediterranean Change') deliver on the promise shown in the main film, with a direct link to those booking pages.

Additional Notes

Credits

Title:Change
Brand:Princess Cruises
Product Category:Cruise Line
Parent Entity:Carnival Corporation & plc
Campaign Category:Brand Building,Brand Awareness
Campaign Objective:Brand Awareness
Creative Format:Lifestyle/Aspirational
Visual Style:Live Action
Target Audience Primary:Multi-generational
Geographic Scope:Global
Platform Focus:Connected TV/OTT
Cultural Context:Year-round/Evergreen
Market Position:Market Leader
Runtime:1:34
Geography:United States
Agency:Omelet
Director:Arnaud Uyttenhove
Creative Team:Florian Bodet (Creative Director), Tiffany Lam (Sr. Art Director), Ernesto Campabadal (Sr. Copywriter)
Production Company:Caviar
Music Composer:Ed Dunne
Sound Designer:Michael Anastasi
Campaign Launch Date:2018-01

Share this Analysis